Did you know New Jersey is the diner capital of the world? It’s no wonder it fits in so well with this show! But that’s not all the Garden State has to offer. From classic American diners to diverse international cuisine, there’s a lot to savor. I can’t wait to dig into this list and see what gluten-free options we can discover!
Atlantic City
- Kelsey & Kim’s Southern Cafe: (Season 22, Episode 1) Southern comfort food that hits the spot every time.
- Vagabond Kitchen & Tap House: (Season 24, Episode 5) A cool spot with a wide selection of beers and creative dishes.
Barnegat Light
- Mustache Bill’s Diner: (Season 2, Episode 13 & Season 21, Episode 15) A retro diner serving up classic American breakfasts and lunches.
Belmar
- 10th Ave Burrito Co: (Season 10, Episode 12 & Season 23, Episode 15) Burritos and Mexican eats that are packed with flavor.
Bridgewater Township
- Big Pinks BBQ: Barbecue done right, with all the smoky, savory goodness you crave.
Brigantine
- Ernest & Son: (Season 21, Episode 12) A butcher shop and deli serving some of the best sandwiches around.
Cape May
- George’s Place: (Season 10, Episode 10) A cozy spot known for its Greek-inspired dishes.
Chatham
- Marie’s Italian Specialties: (Season 16, Episode 6) Looks like this restaurant closed since the show. What a bummer!
Clifton
- Tick Tock Diner: (Season 2, Episode 13) A classic New Jersey diner with a menu that has something for everyone.
Edison
- Skylark Diner: (Season 2, Episode 13) A modern twist on the traditional diner experience.
Hackensack
- White Manna Hamburgers: (Season 2, Episode 13) Known for their sliders, a must-visit for burger lovers.
Hamilton Township
- Jersey Girl Cafe: (Season 25, Episode 13) A charming cafe with a menu full of fresh, tasty options.
Highlands
- The Chubby Pickle: A laid-back spot with great food and live music.
Hightstown
- Hightstown Diner: (Season 2, Episode 13) Another gem in New Jersey’s diner crown, serving classic diner fare.
Hoboken
- La Isla Restaurant: (Season 16, Episode 3) Cuban cuisine that brings the flavors of Havana to New Jersey.
Jersey City
- Brownstone Diner: (Season 3, Episode 3) Known for its pancakes and extensive diner menu.
Lake Hopatcong
- Jefferson Diner: (Season 2, Episode 13) A local favorite for hearty meals and friendly service.
Leeds Point
- Oyster Creek Inn: (Season 21, Episode 13) Seafood lovers, this is your spot for fresh catches.
Linden
- Bay Way Diner: (Season 1, Episode 11 & Season 10, Episode 7) One of the smallest diners with some of the biggest flavors.
Livingston
- The Ritz Diner: (Season 2, Episode 13) A stylish diner offering a broad menu of American classics.
Middletown
- Haldi Chowk Indian Bistro: Delicious Indian dishes with rich, authentic flavors.
Northfield
- Carluccio’s Coal Fired Pizza: (Season 22, Episode 7) Coal-fired pizza that’s crisp and full of flavor.
Ocean City
- Piccini Wood Fired Brick Oven Pizza: (Season 23, Episode 14) Another great pizza spot, known for its wood-fired pies.
Plainsboro Township
- Bagel Street: (Season 25, Episode 8) Fresh bagels and more for a perfect start to your day.
Pleasantville
- Sam’s Rialto Bar & Grill: (Season 24, Episode 3) A friendly bar and grill with a menu full of favorites.
Princeton
- Jammin’ Crepes: (Season 25, Episode 11) Creative crepes with fresh, local ingredients.
Robbinsville Township
- Dolce & Clemente’s: (Season 26, Episode 3) Italian market and eatery with a wide range of delicious options.
Rocky Hill
- Rocky Hill Inn: (Season 25, Episode 9) A historic inn serving elevated pub fare.
Sea Bright
- Moo Yai Thai: Authentic Thai dishes bursting with flavor.
Somers Point
- Grilled Cheese & Crab Cake Co.: (Season 22, Episode 6) Exactly what it sounds like: indulgent and delicious.
- The Anchorage Tavern: (Season 22, Episode 5) A historic tavern with hearty meals and a great atmosphere.
Somerville
- Turf Surf & Earth: Offers a variety of dishes catering to all tastes.
South Bound Brook
- Joe’s Meat Market: Known for its quality meats and sandwiches.
Stone Harbor
- Quahog’s Seafood Shack: (Season 12, Episode 3) Fresh seafood with a laid-back vibe.
Vincentown
- Vincentown Diner: (Season 25, Episode 9) A standout diner with farm-to-table offerings.
Wildwood
- Maui’s Dog House: (Season 10, Episode 13) Hot dogs with a creative twist.
From hearty breakfasts and mouthwatering BBQ to international flavors and fresh seafood, New Jersey’s food scene is diverse and delicious. Each spot offers something unique, and I can’t wait to explore these gems and discover their gluten-free options. Let’s dig in, Guy style!

